Skip to main content

What will you take home?

Compare a PAYE umbrella, a director umbrella, working as a sole trader and your own limited company. Free, no sign-up, no personal details.

At €500 a day, working as a sole trader leaves the most cash: €71,693.88 a year before your own costs.

Which route fits you?
PAYE umbrellaDirector umbrellaMost cashSole trader
Take-home a year€64,170.75€71,342.81€71,693.88
A month€5,347.56€5,945.23€5,974.49
Into your MyFutureFund pension+ €2,966.20——
Set aside a month——€3,692.18
Illness BenefitYesNoNo
Form 11 every yearNot usuallyYesYes

PAYE umbrella

€64,170.75a year

€5,347.56 a month

+ €2,966.20 into your MyFutureFund pension

Illness Benefit
Yes
Form 11 every year
Not usually

Director umbrella

€71,342.81a year

€5,945.23 a month

Illness Benefit
No
Form 11 every year
Yes

Sole trader

Most cash

€71,693.88a year

€5,974.49 a month

Set aside €3,692.18 a month

Illness Benefit
No
Form 11 every year
Yes

Estimate based on what you've told us and 2026 rules (engine v0.7.2, rates ie-2026). Not a Revenue assessment. How we worked this out

The director model: what you gain and give up

More cash than a PAYE umbrella, because there's no employer PRSI.

What you give up

  • No Illness Benefit: self-employed PRSI (Class S) does not include it.
  • No auto-enrolment pension.
  • A provider says the model is "not suitable for mortgage applications".
  • You take on a company director’s duties.
  • The Department of Social Protection decides your PRSI class and can decide it differently.

You must file a Form 11 every year while you're a director. If it's late, there's a surcharge of 5% of your whole year's tax if it's up to 2 months late, or 10% after that (€2,145.86 or €4,291.72 at €500 a day), even though payroll already took the tax.

We show the director model as information only. TaxZone doesn't refer anyone to director-model providers.

Should I set up a limited company?

If you take all the profit out each year, a one-person company leaves you about the same or less than a sole trader. It helps when you leave money in the company or pay into a pension.

These figures include €3,000.00 of business expenses and accountant costs (€600.00 as a sole trader, €2,400.00 for a company).

Take it all out
OptionTaxTake-home a yearCompared with a sole trader
Sole trader, same costs€42,317.57 €70,082.43 —
Your company, all salary€41,005.30€69,594.70 −€487.73
Your company, €44,000.00 salary plus dividends €8,325.00 company tax + €36,656.52 personal tax €65,618.48 −€4,463.95

Dividends have 25% withheld, but that isn't the final tax. Expect about €14,570.45 more on your Form 11.

A company also means company registration, its beneficial owners, a corporation tax return (CT1), an annual return (B1), payroll and dividend withholding tax returns.

Every figure TaxZone shows is an estimate until your return is filed.